Best animal tail butt plug for 2024 – Cleaning and buyer guide included

*SexToyZine.com is reader-supported. When you buy through Amazon and affiliated sites links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission (at no extra cost to you). Learn more.

Once my husband and I tried the first animal tail butt plug, we spent months trying to find the optimal ones for us to play with. The idea got us, but the reality didn’t look so good at the start.

The animal tail butt plugs that we were able to find, both at local sex shops and online, were a total lottery. Some were great, but some just weren’t worth the money.

So I may say that we spent a small fortune until we found quality toys we’re sticking with. That’s why I’ve compiled a list of my favorite ones and picked out what I consider to be the best animal tail butt plug at the moment.

Whatever you pick, you probably won’t go wrong and you can discretely order online any of them. We hope this will help you to find your favorite and have an enjoyable play with your partner at your favorite banging place.

Best animal tail butt plug for the money

I made a list of the best butt plugs with a tail that I and my hubby have tried out by now.

Below you’ll find my short reviews for each of them, which means I’ll try to convey a realistic feel in terms of size, materials, reasons for buying one, and negatives about them if there are any.

I’ll also write about personal experience in terms of pleasure, maintenance, and general impression.

I’ll also add links to the stores where we bought our animal tail butt plugs, so you can be sure to get the same prices, quality of toys, and service as we did. I hope it helps you pick your pleasure plug of choice.

	Price	Model
	Check price	16. Pink pig tail butt plug
	Check price	15. Bad kitty tail butt plug
	Check price	14. Bunny tail butt plug by Tailz
	Check price	13. Woof puppy tail butt plug
	Check price	12. Glass pig butt plug
	Check price	11. White cat tail butt plug
	Check price	10. Fox tail anal plug by Tailz
	Check price	9. SexySamba rabbit tail butt plug
	Check price	8. Pony tail butt plug by nsnovelties
	Check price	7. Wolf tail butt plug by Tailz
	Check price	6. Good boy! dog tail butt plug
	Check price	5. Unicorn butt plug
	Check price	4. Foxxxy's faux fox tail butt plug
	Check price	3. Tailz horse tail butt plug
	Check price	2. Frisky fox tail butt plug
	Check price	1. Crystal Minx Detachable Furry Tail Butt Plug

16. Pink pigtail butt plug

Coming in sexy pink and black color, this butt plug with the animal tail by XR Brands is a true delight if you want to unleash your dirty Lil’ swine. It is phthalate-free and made from a firm rubber, which is easy to clean and slide where you want it.

You get around 4 inches long plug, 1.25 inches in diameter, and another 5 inches of spiraled tail. This pigtail butt plug fits nicely in its place and the spiraled tail only adds to its charm.

In my humble opinion, it can be a great fit for beginners, but I’d recommend it to experienced users too. The limiter of this pigtail butt plug can go way deep if you get too horny, which may be a problem for those who can’t take much in.

Check today’s price

15. Bad kitty tail butt plug

Meow, here we come to another interesting animal tail butt plug made by Frisky. A flexible faux fur tail plug and premium silicone will unleash the inner cat in you and make you purr all day!

This kitten butt plug may look pretty basic, but it’s an excellent choice for beginners. It has handy pulls for getting the plug gently out, without destroying the tail, which is excellent, and yet it doesn’t mess with you while you wear it.

The silicone of which the plug is made is hypoallergenic, phthalate-free, and non-porous, which makes it safe even for long wearing. The tail itself is made of soft faux fur and can be bent as you like.

The total length of this kitty tail butt plug is 28 inches, 4 inches of the insertable plug, which is 1.4 inches wide.

Check today’s price

14. Bunny tail butt plug by Tailz

This cute little animal tail butt plug features a metal anal plug along with a faux fur bunny tail on its top. But don’t underestimate this faux fur tail plug because it’s small – the rippled design makes you feel wonderful sensations on your way there.

The plug itself is made of colored aluminum, which makes it safe for people prone to allergies and it is generally one of the best made from these that we’ve tried.

Aluminum is a lot lighter than stainless steel so you won’t have a feeling that it will fall out if you move. As I’ve said, this bunny tail butt plug is on the smaller end, regarding size.

The whole length of this bunny tail plug is 5 inches, 2 of which are insertable. The tapered design of this bunny tail butt plug will make things go super-smooth in and out and its faux fur is more than charming. So go ahead, bunnies enjoy your carrots.

Check today’s price

13. Woof puppy tail butt plug

Let’s get back to the basic animal tail butt plugs. This puppy butt plug is for those who want to skip fancy stuff and enjoy more of the practical side.

This puppy tail butt plug is in no way made for beginners since it’s quite big. Its total length is 12.7 inches, 4.25 inches of which are insertable and the plug’s diameter is 2.4 inches.

It’s no wonder this puppy tail butt plug is called Woof XL. This puppy butt plug is made of premium, hypoallergenic silicone without phthalates and is super easy to clean.

Just make sure you don’t use it with silicone-based lubes. And yes, the flared bottom of the plug is a special treat!

Check today’s price

12. Glass pig butt plug

I know I’ve picked my favorite among piggies, but I just have to mention this pig butt plug. It’s also on the smaller end regarding size, but it’s made of hypoallergenic, very firm, borosilicate glass, which makes it my favorite for several reasons.

First, it’s super-smooth to use. Second, it’s super-easy to clean and bacteria-safe, meaning there’s no way some dirt could be stuck in its pores, etc. Plus, this pig butt plug can be safely used in water, which means you can adapt its temperature to your likes.

Regarding size, its total length is 7.25 inches, 3.25 inches of which are insertable and its diameter is 1.5 inches. This glass tail plug looks great – it comes in sexy smokey jade color and has s small, seductive, curly, piggy tail.

I know that those who want something big up in their butt probably won’t be thrilled, but in my experience, this pig butt plug is just a must-have!

Check today’s price

11. White cat tail butt plug

I’ve mentioned the kitty tail butt plug, but let’s take the play-up among the adult, horny cats. Honestly, I think no one can resist the look of this cat tail butt plug. But this high-end cat tail plug is not just pretty.

Yes, its tail is made from fluffy faux fur in white color and its name says it mimics the tail of arctic mink. But let’s be honest here… This animal tail butt plug will make you a pure, fancy, high-class cat, so I’ve sorted it as a cat tail butt plug.

The plug is made from aluminum by XR Brands. It is super-light to wear, easy to insert, and somewhat on the smaller end size-wise. The plug is 1.5 inches wide and 3 inches long.

Check today’s price

10. Fox tail anal plug by Tailz

With this fox tail anal plug, I’m getting us back to the forest animals and glass anal plugs. This midsize fox tail anal plug is just somewhere in the middle – great for both experienced users and beginners.

Plus, it has that wonderful material I prefer when it comes to sex toys – the butt plug itself is made of glass. I’ve already mentioned why I love it so much – it’s hygienic, smooth, and just good-looking.

The fox anal tail is made of fluffy faux fur, which is 13 inches (33 cm) long. The glass butt plug is 4 inches (10 cm) long and 1.5 inches (3.8 cm) wide. The foxtail comes in black color only.

I’ve wanted that foxy-orange one, but this one also played its role very well. Anyway, excellent butt plug for an excellent price.

Check today’s price

9. SexySamba rabbit tail butt plug

Yeah, we had a bunny tail butt plug, but this rabbit butt plug is more like Jessica Rabbit type for quite a decent price. This rabbit tail butt plug is super sexy, as the tail is the only thing you will see and it looks just awesome among the butt cheeks.

It comes in tons of colors but we took the white one and we fell in love with it. It also comes in 3 sizes, so you can pick one fitting your preferences (we took the “fattest” one, with 0.16 inches aka 40 mm diameter and it felt right).

The butt plug is made of quality alloy and I had no issues using it. For me, everything goes smoothly if you put a bit of lube on it.

I’m not sure how this one would go with those allergic to some metals, as there’s no detailed specification on the alloy, but for me works wonders, especially for such a price.

Check today’s price

8. Pony tail butt plug by nsnovelties

This ponytail butt plug looks more like some unicorn tail or My little pony butt plug, so make sure you keep it away from your children, as they will think it’s some kind of beautiful toy for them.

You can pick between three colors: pink, blue, and yellow. We took pink, as it looks the prettiest of all three to me. It looks totally fun and it works well, too. Mind that it’s on the smaller side of butt plugs.

The butt plug itself is 0.75 inches wide and 4 inches long and has 3.5 insertable inches. It is made of silky smooth and hypoallergenic silicone and it’s phthalate and latex-free.

Although I’m not sure about the material on the tail, I think it’s some kind of faux hair used on dolls. All in all, this ponytail butt plug is a bit thin for my taste, but a lot of fun and in a nice range of price, so we just had to put it in our favorites.

Check today’s price

7. Wolf tail butt plug by Tailz

This one is the only wolf tail plug we’re able to find and test and we wondered why there are no other wolf tail butt plugs. Does no one like to play big bad wolf? I surely doubt it. So this is my call to manufacturers to give us more options.

This wolf tail butt plug came in a set with ears and is made by XR Brands. It comes in two colors: gray and white and is on the higher end regarding price, but when you mind the fact that you get ears too, then it’s justified.

The butt plug is hypoallergenic, and made of phthalate and latex-free silicone. It’s 4.50 inches long, 4 of which are insertable. The tail, made of faux fur, is 19 inches long.

Check today’s price

6. Good boy! dog tail butt plug

Unlike other toys mentioned, this rubber puppy tail has one wonderful advantage – a vibrating function with wireless remote control. If you want to see your partner shaking her/his tail from pleasure like a real puppy, then this dog tail butt plug is the toy you may want to have.

The rubber puppy tail’s end weights it, so at the slightest shake, it will wag like a real one. You can use your remote controller to send shivering waves of pleasure deep inside your lover from up to 23 feet.

5 different modes of vibration will make sure that no one is left behind when it comes to pleasure. The anal plug is also made of phthalate-free rubber and has a contoured base for a better fit and to keep the tail upright when on point.

The whole dog tail butt plug is 7.50 inches long, has 3.50 inches of insertable length and the plug has a diameter of 1.80 inches. The remote controller uses 1 23A- 12V battery (included in the package) and 2 AAA batteries (not included in the package).

This one may be one of the heaviest toys on this list (15.52 ounces) but its vibration function makes it worth the investment.

Check today’s price

5. Unicorn butt plug

I’ve mentioned My little pony butt plug that looks like one, but this one is the real unicorn butt plug. The manufacturer is the same, NS Novelties but this unicorn anal plug isn’t thin as his cousin.

It comes in rainbow colors and I suppose it just looks great on any ass. This kinky unicorn butt plug is made of hypoallergenic silicone without phthalates or latex.

It is 12.6 inches long, 3.9 inches of which are insertable and the plug is 2.1 inches wide. The butt plug comes in black color and the tail is made of some faux hair material in simply wonderful shades of rainbow colors.

Check today’s price

4. Foxxxy’s faux fox tail butt plug

Foxxxy’s faux fox tail butt plug made my wish come true and got me a foxy-orange faux fox tail plug, plus it’s wonderfully made of durable borosilicate glass. This smooth toy not only looks wonderful but also feels heavenly inside.

The plug itself is 4.5 inches long, 4 inches of which are insertable and the plug is 1.46 inches wide in its “fattest” points. The cleaning is super-easy, and the toy is hypoallergenic and can be used with any lube.

I suppose its size is high-end for beginners and on smaller size for more experienced people, but this faux fox tail butt plug is so wonderful by color, feel, and also price, that I think everyone needs to have it in her/his private toy collection.

The tail may be a bit shorter than I’d wanted to, but that only makes it easier to store and clean in the end, so it’s no big deal.

Check today’s price

3. Tailz horse tail butt plug

This is our favorite horse tail butt plug! It’s a bit bigger so maybe not the best choice if you’re a beginner, but it only takes a bit of lube, practice, and nice petting to get it nicely in there.

It is made from smooth, phthalate-free, thermoplastic rubber and the tail is made of faux hair. The tail itself comes in two colors: brown and blonde.

This horse tail butt plug has 22.5 inches in total length, 4.5 inches of which go to the plug (3.75 inches insertable) and its diameter is 1.75 inches. The flared base is quite big and it keeps the plug firmly in place.

Plus, you can also use its tail like a flogger.

Check today’s price

2. Frisky fox tail butt plug

Yeah, I know, it’s quite obvious I like foxes, but there’s something wonderful about this fox tail plug that keeps it one of my favorite fox tail butt plugs for a few months.

First of all, it’s the most realistic fox tail plug (and animal tail butt plug in general) out there. Period. It also has one of the longest tails (14 inches), which gives it a special charm.

I feel connected with my animal side while I wear it. The faux fur on the tail is wonderfully fluffy and the plug itself is also great. It’s 4.5 inches long, 4 inches of which are insertable and it’s 1.46 inches wide.

This fox tail butt plug is made of phthalate-free thermoplastic rubber, so it’s not kind of great for those with allergies to latex, but luckily, I don’t have issues.

It may fit both beginners and experienced users and its base keeps it securely in place for hours of wearing. What does the fox say?

Check today’s price

1. Crystal Minx Detachable Furry Tail Butt Plug

I listed this toy as the best animal tail butt plugs for several reasons. First, you could already notice that I prefer my animal butt plug to be made of firm glass since it gives me much easier options for hygiene and cleaning.

But the best thing about this furry tail butt plug is that it comes with a detachable animal tail. That makes cleaning a piece of cake! I simply detach the tail and put the plug in the dishwasher or clean it without fear of ruining the tail.

Since it’s made of glass, you won’t bother with allergies and sensitivities. But that is just the beginning… This manufacturer, Crystal Delights, makes these wonderful glass plugs in 3 sizes: Small, Medium, and Large. Each bulb can be combined with tons of tails!

So, for example, when you get bored playing with, let’s say, your wolf tail, simply detach it from the plug and attach another to your liking. You can choose from a variety of tails like faux bunny tail, unicorn, pony, leopard, reindeer tail, faux foxtail, and even real fox tail!

The price is on the higher end, but hey, so is the toy! Did I say you can choose the length of your tail, too? Yeah!

Check today’s price

User guide for an animal tail butt plug

Pet play tail plug do’s and don’ts

When it comes to pet play tail plugs, there are a few things we should skip doing if we want them to last.

Plus, there are some things we should always do if we want to make the most of our faux fur tail plugs. And when it comes to pleasure, there’s no need to withhold anything.

1. Never pull out the plug by holding the tail.

Animal tails are usually glued to the base of the plug, so by doing this, you may be turning your wonderful investment into a sad one.

If the base of the plug doesn’t have loops, then the safest way to pull out the plug is by holding it for its flared base.

Make sure you pull it out gently to avoid hurting yourself or your partner.

2. Always, always use lube

Check user manuals to see which kinds of lubes are compatible with your plug. The wrong type of lube may damage your plug.

For example, silicone plugs are not compatible with silicone-based lubricants. The mucous membranes of the anus are very sensitive, no matter how much one is relaxed or horny.

By using appropriate lube, you’ll ensure that the play goes safe, and smooth, and even enhance the sensations.

If there are no indications about lube on your toy’s user manual, then I’d say it’s the best bet to go with water-based lubes.

3. Don’t wash furry tails in dishwashers

Some pet play tail plugs that are made of silicone and rubber may be washed in dishwashers, as is suggested over the web, but I just don’t suggest it.

I wash my toys either in lukewarm water with mild soap or clean them with sex toy cleaners. The best is to follow your manufacturer’s instructions.

But if there aren’t any, just don’t ever wash your faux hair or fur tail plugs in the dishwasher or any kind of washing machine. If there are no instructions, the hand wash is the safest bet.

How to clean a butt plug with an animal tail?

When it comes to cleaning your butt plugs with a tail, make sure you clean them before the first use and after each one. The best advice, as I’ve said, would be to follow the instructions in your user manual, but sometimes there aren’t any.

In these cases, I practice the safest way – by washing my butt plug with the animal tail by hand in warm soapy water.

If the tail is made of faux hair or fur, then I use gentle hair shampoo and a bit of conditioner – from time to time. Otherwise, when I clean my rubber/silicone toys I use either antibacterial sex toy cleaners or gentle antibacterial liquid soap.

In both cases, I make sure to rinse the soaping agents well under clean water and air dry them well before storing them. Then I put them in a clean ziplock bag and store them in my toy box, far from prying eyes and reach of children.

And when it comes to hygiene, never share your sex toys. If it happens to be so, for example, if you’re practicing group sex, at least make sure that you’re using a condom between play to avoid STDs and bacteria.

Conclusion

I hope I gave you enough information to make a good choice and invest in some of these kinky beauties. At the end, when it comes to animal tail butt plugs or any other sex toy, it all narrows down by your personal preferences.

I’ve tried to give you all the info that you may want to know before buying some and I hope I’ve managed to share the feeling when using each of them. I hope you get the right one for you and spend hours of joy unleashing your inner animal!